Updated March 25, 2026 · Data from NYPD, 311, Citizen, community reports
Old-school Italian-American neighborhood with deep front gardens, Carroll Park, and Smith Street's mix of longtime red-sauce joints and new-wave eateries.
Carroll Gardens currently holds a A safety grade, meaning it has very safe. Over the last 30 days there were 6 reported incidents in the area. Safety varies by time of day and block.
What is the safest time to walk in Carroll Gardens?
Based on 90 days of incident data, Evening (6pm–12am) has the fewest reported incidents (2). Afternoon (12pm–6pm) sees the most activity (4 incidents).
How does Carroll Gardens compare to the rest of Brooklyn?
Carroll Gardens logged 6 incidents in the last 30 days. View the full comparison section for borough and citywide context.
What types of incidents are most common in Carroll Gardens?
The most reported categories are: homeless (6).
Is Carroll Gardens getting safer or more dangerous?
Compared to the prior 30-day period, incidents are up. The 90-day trend provides a more stable picture.